New Financial Advisor? What to Ask Before You Stay
If your financial advisor is retiring, you may assume the person taking over your accounts is the natural choice to continue managing your money. That may be true, but it is worth taking the time to find out.
A new financial advisor can have a very different investment philosophy, fee structure, planning process, or approach to retirement than the advisor you have worked with for years.
That matters even more when you are approaching or already in retirement.
Before agreeing to continue the relationship, ask these eight questions to understand exactly who will be managing your money and whether they are the right fit for the years ahead.
Even if your advisor isn’t retireing now this may still be worht a read as according to J.D. Power’s 2025 Financial Advisor Satisfaction Study, 46% of financial advisors surveyed plan to retire within the next 10 years, highlighting how many investors could soon find themselves working with a new financial advisor.
Keep reading, or if you prefer to listen or watch… check out the Podcast or full YouTube video.
Why You Should Evaluate a New Financial Advisor
Advisor succession is becoming an increasingly important issue for investors. When an established advisor retires, clients may be transitioned to someone younger or to another advisor within the firm.
That transition does not necessarily mean the new advisor was selected specifically because they are the best match for you.
Financial advisory practices also have economic value. In some situations, another advisor may purchase all or part of a retiring advisor’s business. As a result, the person who takes over your accounts could have different investment strategies, services, fees, or planning philosophies.
Your retirement savings are too important to simply assume everything will remain the same.
Treat the transition as an opportunity to interview your new financial advisor and decide whether you would choose that person yourself.
1. Are You a Fiduciary at All Times?
Start with one of the most important questions you can ask a financial advisor:
Are you a fiduciary at all times?
A fiduciary is required to provide advice that is in your best interest. Understanding when and how that obligation applies can help you identify potential conflicts of interest. Some financial professionals operate under different standards depending on the account or service they are providing. That distinction may not be obvious to the client.
Ask your new financial advisor to explain their fiduciary responsibility clearly, including whether it applies to every account they manage for you.
You should understand how they are compensated as well.
Commissions, product incentives, and other forms of compensation can affect the economics of certain recommendations. Knowing how your advisor gets paid gives you additional context when evaluating their advice.
2. What Is My Total Cost in Year One?
An advisory fee is only one piece of the cost of managing an investment portfolio.
For example, an advisor may charge a percentage of the assets they manage. Additional expenses could potentially include investment costs, transaction expenses, product fees, or other charges.
Ask your new financial advisor for the total estimated cost of the relationship, not simply the headline advisory fee.
Questions may include:
- What percentage am I paying for investment management?
- Are there additional account or trading costs?
- Do any of my investments carry separate fees?
- Are commissions involved?
- Have any fees changed since my previous advisor managed the account?
No advisor should be expected to work for free. The goal is simply to understand what you are paying and what you are receiving in return.
Fees that appear small on an annual basis can become meaningful over a long retirement.
3. Can I See an Example Financial Plan?
Investment management and financial planning are not the same thing.
A portfolio of stocks and bonds may be an important part of retirement planning, but retirees often face decisions that extend well beyond asset allocation.
Ask your new financial advisor if you can see a redacted example of a financial plan. The example can help you determine how deeply the advisor approaches retirement planning.
A comprehensive process may consider areas such as:
- Social Security
- Healthcare expenses
- Tax planning
- Roth conversions
- Required minimum distributions
- Withdrawal strategies
- HSA planning
- Estate planning
- Investment management
Seeing the actual planning process can tell you much more than hearing someone say they provide “holistic financial planning.”
You want to know whether your advisor is building a retirement strategy or primarily managing investments.
4. How Do You Plan for the Years Between Retirement and RMDs?
The years immediately after retirement can present valuable planning opportunities.
For many retirees, there is a period between leaving the workforce and beginning required minimum distributions. Income may temporarily be lower during those years.
That window can create opportunities to evaluate strategies such as Roth conversions and other tax-planning decisions.
Ask your new financial advisor how they specifically approach those years. More importantly, find out what causes them to recommend action.
Do they have specific triggers they monitor? Will they review the opportunity every year? How do taxes factor into the decision?
A strong retirement planning process should not rely on making these decisions at the last minute.
Your advisor should have a system for evaluating opportunities as your retirement evolves.
5. How Often Will We Meet?
Communication expectations should be established before you commit to a new advisory relationship. Ask how often the advisor typically meets with retirement clients.
Some advisors schedule annual meetings. Others may meet semiannually or quarterly depending on the client’s needs and the services being provided.
The frequency itself is not necessarily the most important issue.
What matters is knowing what to expect.
Find out whether meetings are proactively scheduled by the advisor or whether clients are expected to initiate them. Ask how the advisor communicates when an issue comes up between scheduled reviews.
Retirement can involve decisions about taxes, investments, Social Security, healthcare, estate planning, and withdrawals.
You want a new financial advisor who will be available when those decisions need to be made.
6. How Did You Handle the Last Major Market Downturn?
Markets are relatively easy to discuss when they are rising.
A downturn can tell you much more about an advisor’s philosophy. Ask your prospective advisor what they told clients during the last major market decline.
Were they making significant portfolio changes? Did they encourage clients to stay disciplined? Were they attempting to predict short-term market movements?
Listen closely to the reasoning behind their decisions.
Their answer can help you determine whether their investment philosophy aligns with yours.
It may also reveal how they communicate when markets become stressful.
You are not simply evaluating performance. You are trying to understand the process behind the decisions.
7. Will You Coordinate With My Other Professionals?
Retirement planning rarely happens in isolation.
Your financial decisions may involve your CPA, estate planning attorney, insurance professionals, and other specialists.
Ask whether your new financial advisor helps coordinate those relationships.
An advisor does not need to be an expert in every area. However, someone overseeing your financial plan should understand how the different pieces work together.
For example, an estate plan may establish certain intentions for your assets. Beneficiary designations on retirement or investment accounts also need to align with those intentions.
Tax strategies can involve similar coordination.
A financial advisor who communicates with your CPA can help ensure investment and retirement decisions are considered alongside their potential tax consequences.
Think of your advisor as the quarterback of your financial life rather than simply another player on the field.
8. What Is My Exit Strategy?
It may seem strange to discuss leaving a financial advisor before you have even decided to work with them.
That is exactly why you should ask.
Find out what happens if you decide six months, two years, or even ten years from now that the relationship is no longer right for you.
- Can your investments transfer easily?
- Are there surrender charges?
- Do any products have holding periods or penalties?
Certain financial products, including some annuities, can include surrender schedules that make exiting expensive for a period of time.
Understanding those restrictions before investing is considerably easier than discovering them after you decide you want to leave.
A good relationship should begin with a clear understanding of how it can end.
Don’t Automatically Stay With a New Financial Advisor
A longtime advisor retiring can feel disruptive, especially when that person has guided your finances for years. Still, the transition gives you an opportunity.
Instead of automatically remaining with whoever takes over the practice, evaluate the new financial advisor the same way you would evaluate someone you were hiring from scratch.
Ask about fiduciary responsibility, fees, retirement planning, tax strategy, communication, investment philosophy, professional coordination, and your ability to leave.
These conversations do not need to take hours. In roughly 30 minutes, you can learn a great deal about how an advisor operates and whether their approach fits what you want for your retirement.
The decision matters because small differences in fees, taxes, investment decisions, and retirement planning can compound over many years.
Your financial advisor may have retired, your responsibility for choosing who manages the next stage of your financial life has not.
Considering a New Financial Advisor?
If your financial advisor has retired, your accounts have been transferred to someone new, or you are questioning whether your current advisor is still the right fit, a second opinion can help.
At Bonfire Financial, we look beyond investment allocation to understand how your investments, retirement income, taxes, Social Security, estate planning, and long-term goals work together.
Before signing anything with a new financial advisor, take the time to understand your options.
Schedule a conversation with us to get a second set of eyes on your retirement plan.
Client Login